Key points at a glance
- Time clocks and terminals record time at a fixed location, an app anywhere.
- For businesses with a single site, a terminal is robust and simple.
- On construction sites and in field service, the time clock reaches its limits.
- Fingerprint terminals process biometric data and are sensitive under data protection law.
- Many businesses combine both: a terminal on site and an app for mobile employees.
Contents
- What types of time tracking are there?
- Advantages of time clocks and terminals
- Disadvantages of time clocks and terminals
- Fingerprint terminals and data protection
- Advantages of a time tracking app
- Disadvantages of a time tracking app
- The comparison at a glance
- Combining both
- Co-determination of the works council
- Which solution suits your business?
What types of time tracking are there?
- Mechanical time clock: Employees insert a time card and the clock prints the time on it. The cards are evaluated by hand.
- Time tracking terminal: Employees clock in with a chip, card or PIN. Times are stored digitally and transferred to software.
- Biometric terminal: Employees identify themselves by fingerprint or facial recognition.
- Time tracking app: Employees clock in by smartphone or in the browser, wherever they are.
Advantages of time clocks and terminals
- No smartphone needed: Every employee can clock in, even without a company phone.
- Fast and unambiguous: One tap of the card at the entrance, no app or login.
- Robust: Terminals are built for continuous use in workshops and production.
Disadvantages of time clocks and terminals
- Only in one place: Anyone who drives straight to a construction site or a customer cannot clock in, so paper slips are needed again.
- Purchase and maintenance: Device, installation and software cost money, and every additional site needs its own device.
- Buddy punching: With a card or chip, one colleague can clock in for another.
- Only arrival and departure: Many terminals do not record project time.
Fingerprint terminals and data protection
Fingerprints and facial data are biometric data and, under Art. 9 GDPR, belong to the special categories of personal data. Processing them is only permitted within narrow limits. In 2020, the Regional Labour Court of Berlin-Brandenburg ruled that an employer was not allowed to introduce fingerprint time tracking without consent because it was not necessary for this purpose (judgment of 4 June 2020, 10 Sa 2130/19). Review biometric methods particularly carefully, ideally with your data protection officer.
Advantages of a time tracking app
- Usable anywhere: Employees clock in where they work, including on construction sites or at the customer's premises.
- No hardware: There is no device to install or maintain.
- More than arrival and departure: Many apps also record project time, vacation and duty rosters.
- Location as proof: Depending on the app, the location is saved with the timestamp.
Disadvantages of a time tracking app
- Smartphone needed: As a rule, you cannot unilaterally require employees to use their private smartphone. Provide company phones or offer clocking in via the browser.
- Internet connection: Depending on the app, clocking in requires a connection.
- Location data: This is personal data too. Only record it for a clear purpose, such as proving working time and work location.
The comparison at a glance
| Time clock and terminal | Time tracking app | |
|---|---|---|
| Where time is recorded | At the device, usually at the entrance | Anywhere by smartphone or browser |
| Purchase | Device, installation and software | No hardware, ongoing licence fees |
| Without a smartphone | Yes | Only in the browser |
| Construction sites and field service | Only with additional paper slips | Yes |
| Buddy punching | Possible with someone else's card | Harder thanks to personal login |
| Project time | Rarely | Often |
| Vacation and duty roster | Usually a separate solution | In the same system, depending on the provider |
Combining both
For many businesses the right answer is not one solution or the other but both: a terminal at the workshop or hall entrance for employees on site and an app for everyone on the move. What matters is that all times end up in one system so that reports do not have to be done twice.
Co-determination of the works council
Terminals and apps are technical facilities capable of monitoring employees' behaviour and performance. If you have a works council, it must agree to their introduction under § 87 (1) no. 6 BetrVG. This applies regardless of which solution you choose.
Which solution suits your business?
- One site, fixed working hours: A terminal is a solid choice.
- Construction sites, field service, changing work locations: An app records time where the work is done.
- Both in your business: Combine a terminal on site with an app for mobile employees.
How SWTracker helps
SWTracker is built for mobile time tracking: your employees clock in with the Companion App for iOS and Android or in the browser, and every timestamp is saved with the location. For businesses that also need hardware, such as a fixed terminal at the workshop entrance or a remote control for opening gates and doors, we offer custom devices as part of our Enterprise solutions.
Frequently asked questions
Is a time clock still up to date?
For businesses with a fixed site, yes. As soon as employees work on the move, an app or a combination of terminal and app is usually the better solution.
Can I require my employees to clock in with their private phone?
As a rule, no. Provide company phones or offer an alternative, such as clocking in via the browser or at a terminal.
Is fingerprint time tracking allowed?
Only within narrow limits, because fingerprints are biometric data. In a 2020 case, the Regional Labour Court of Berlin-Brandenburg found it not necessary. Have such a method reviewed beforehand.
Can I use a terminal and an app at the same time?
Yes, many businesses do. What matters is that all times end up in one system.
Sources
- BAG, decision of 13 September 2022, 1 ABR 22/21
- Art. 9 General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)
- LAG Berlin-Brandenburg, judgment of 4 June 2020, 10 Sa 2130/19
- § 87 Works Constitution Act (BetrVG)
This guide is for general information only and does not replace legal advice.